[HPforGrownups] McGonagall was:Hagrid/the Chamber/the Monster

[Richelle Votaw]

No: HPFGUIDX 49994

Snuffles writes:

> There really isn't a lot to back up this theory in cannon except for the fact 
> that MM has such absolute disdain for Trelawney. It would be interesting to 
> see it come ti fruition, though. I think it's more likely that she has a 3rd 
> sense, but maybe not what is called Seeing by Trelawney's definition.... DD 
> certainly has a psychic sense...

McGonagall's remarks about Trelawney would be quite ironic if indeed McGonagall did turn out to be a Seer.  I don't have much to base this on, in other words, McGonagall doesn't seem the type to sit around looking at tea leaves and into crystal balls.  But is that how a true Seer always sees?  Or is a "true Seer" like someone with a sixth sense/psychic ability?  McGonagall always turns up, she's on Privet Drive (true, someone could've told her that's where Harry was being taken); she arrives with Snape and Quirrell (leading them, in fact) in the troll incident.  When the teachers were *supposed* to be in the dungeons.  Why wasn't she?  How did she know to go there?  Did she follow Quirrell?  Did she follow Snape?  Or just go on her own accord, instead of going to the dungeons?  Anyway, it's just a lot of little things, no big prophecies or anything, just little things that may or may not add up to something.

Richelle


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]