[HPforGrownups] neville longbottom

[snapesrighthand]

No: HPFGUIDX 50180

Opal:
I think Neville will become more important later
on, either as a casualty or 
as an asset. But yes he will have an impact.

Alex: Yes, I agree.  Rowling gave us important
information about Neville.  She kept dropping
hints... like... paraphrase... Harry would have
heard that Nevilles usual snores were not heard.

Opal:
BUT as far Imperius goes, well I have a question:
Does a curse continue to 
function after the caster is dead or
incapacitated? He's been soul sucked - 
which is worse than dead, just a shell.
BTW his parents went mad because of the Cruciatus
Curse, not Imperius (GoF, 
ch 30, page 595 and 603 US paperback). Please
don't get me wrong, I'm not 
jumping down your throat or anything, just trying
to be helpful.

Alex:  I have often wondered if Neville was
tortured to?  Why is he so bad with magic?  Did
he witness his parents being tortured?  Is he
scarred and that is why he can not do magic well?
 Did they put some kind of memory curse on him
dimming his mind so he would not remember
something?  

just my 2 cents
alexandra

__________________________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail Plus - Powerful. Affordable. Sign up now.
http://mailplus.yahoo.com