[HPforGrownups] Re: What will come in book 5

[Maria Kirilenko]

No: HPFGUIDX 50430


--- "Megalynn S." <megalynn44 at hotmail.com> wrote> 
> I myself think Lupin will be killed by Wormtail. The
> fact that he, Wormtail, 
> has been given a silver hand seems to cement that
> for me. It's just the kind 
> of clue JKR likes to leave.

Well, I can only say "Heaven forbid," but I'd like to
question this assumption that "real," i.e. Potterverse
werewolfs can be killed by silver. This wasn't
anywhere in the books, although when in PS and PoA it
was talked on several occasions about vampires, who
have no relation to the books at all so far, garlic
was mentioned as part of the defense against them. 


> 
> Snape I think could be killed trying to do something
> to redeem himself, or 
> shortly after redeeming himself with Harry. I don't
> think it's highly 
> likely, but probable.

Very probable, although I don't think WW can really
spare him yet.

> 
> Hagrid, to me, just seems like the obvious special
> fan and hard death to 
> write, but I haven't given up hope.

I'd bet my money on Hagrid. He's always been the
scapegoat of the WW.

> The only one out of the four listed I would actually
> be mad (very mad) is if 
> Sirius were killed. He has suffered sooooooooo much
> already. I just really 
> want to see him have some happiness.

Ditto, although Lupin has also suffered *a lot.*

Maria,
going off to pick up her sister from dance class.


__________________________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail Plus - Powerful. Affordable. Sign up now.
http://mailplus.yahoo.com