Cauldrons & Bill Weasley
Carolyn <summer2999@aol.com>
summer2999 at aol.com
Mon Jan 27 15:43:29 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 50784
About a week or so ago a made a post, and it never showed up at the
boards, and I also never got an email saying it wouldn't be posted,
so I'm trying again.
My question is about cauldrons. In the first book, a cauldron is on
Harry's school supply list, and he contemplates getting a solid gold
one. My question is, what do the students do with their cauldrons
once they get to school? It's not very practical to think that they
carry their cauldron around with them until Potions class, because
cauldrons are heavy. I also don't think they use them for homework
purposes, because it would make sense that the only potion making
students do is under the watch of Professor Snape--what if something
went wrong? So what then, is the purpose of the cauldron? Also in
CoS, Hermione had a cauldronw with which to brew the Polyjuice
potion. Where did she get it? Why would the students be required
to buy something they never use? The cauldrons that are used in
Potions class, I've always assumed, were just already there. Soo...
does anyone have an explanation for this?
One more thing... I've read discussions in various places about the
full names of the Weasleys. Has anyone considered Bill's full name
to be Bilius? Because in PoA, there is the line, "Ron looked at
Hermione as if she had gone mad. 'Hermione, if Harry's seen a Grim,
that's--that's bad,' he said. 'My--my uncle Bilius saw one and--and
he died twenty-four hours later!'" Has anyone considered the
possibility that Bill was named after his uncle? It would make
sense.
Well that's all I have to say for now. I hope this gets posted, and
I look forward to feedback.
Peace,
Carolyn
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive