MAGIC DISHWASHER question

[Melody <Malady579@hotmail.com>]

No: HPFGUIDX 50952

Kristen asked:
>I have a question for those of you who believe in the MAGIC
>DISHWASHER theory (if you don't know what this is, you can read about
>it at http://www.hpfgu.org.uk/faq/hypotheticalley.html#md) - a very
>interesting theory by the way, I'll have to think about that.
>
>When you think about the publisher's teaser with Dumbledore about to
>tell Harry "everything", do you think he will reveal:
> a. the truth
> b. misinformation to push Harry the direction he needs to go
> c. nothing - he will be prevented from telling Harry anything of
> value


Ok, given that I am the only MDDT up right now, and you were kind
enough to ask (glad *you* find us interesting Kirsten <grin>)....

Do you honestly want to know?

Honestly.  *Honestly.*

Well ok....

MAGICAL DISHWASHER was not created to predict the future of the books.
 It is only created to explain what has happened so far.

Ok, after I dodge the many assorted objects thrown my way...


Sorry!  It is the truth.  Based on MD, no one can say what Dumbledore
is planning now.  We can assume something involving that life dept and
Harry's blood, but honestly, we cannot predict past that.

Harry is growing up.  Dumbledore will give information as he sees
Harry can deal with it.  That seems to be how Dumbledore is working
with Harry so far.

Remember: Dumbledore is trying to *end* this terrorist war with
Voldemort.  He wants to end it with the least amount of pain to all.
If keeping information a secret for the time being, information that
is not detrimental to survival, then Dumbledore's first responsibility
is to the good of the wizard world.


So really...

If Dumbledore still sees it best to keep Harry in the dark, then bully
for Dumbledore.  He has his reasons.

If Dumbledore want to tell Harry the truth, the whole truth, and
nothing but the truth, then he has an extremely good reason there too.

What I can say Kristen, is that Dumbledore, of course, will *not* lie.

:)


Melody
[hope that helped]...[yes I could not resist]