OOtP: <Spoiler> Why Weren't the Weasleys in the Order?
The Kirk
pmah4600 at mail.usyd.edu.au
Tue Jul 1 11:28:56 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 66394
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "snufflesnbeakie"
<bhauersperger at h...> wrote:
> I might have missed this topic of conversation, if it had been
> brought up previously, but I was just re-listening to my audio
tape
> version of OOtP and came across something that made me
wonder. . .
>
> When Lupin was reassuring Mrs. Weasley after her terrible
ordeal
> with the boggart - he said that she hadn't been in the order last
> time, so she wouldn't have known that it was different: i.e., that
> order members where outnumbered 20 to 1 by death eaters.
This time
> it was different. . . And they were not in the photo that Moody
> showed Harry.
>
> But why would the Weasleys not have been in the Order the
last
> time? They would have been old enough, they are obviously
staunch
> supporters of Dumbledore, they are disliked by death eaters -
surely
> they would have been members. This seems like a huge
contradiction
> to me.
>
> Any theories? If it's been previously discussed, I'd really like a
> reminder of what was thrown out!
>
Well, I think the best theory is the one that states Mr and/or Mrs
Weasley were under the influence of the Imperius curse during
the first Voldemort War.
Roo
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive