OOP: Snape and Lily

DieZauberfrau at t-online.de DieZauberfrau at t-online.de
Wed Jul 2 09:32:15 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 66728

Hello,
I'm Astrid from Germany and I just like to know you my oppinon. From 1 book on, I thought Snape isn't that bad
and I can not believe he dislikes Harry that much because
of James. Yes he looks like his father, but if James acted like in Snapes memory, Harry does not act like his father.
I think also there is another reason Snape's hating James.
You remember Lily saying she does not like James and
Snape's words about Lily? When I was in that age I would
not have said, I like this guy in front of so many people, would have said it the other way. Remember Snape was stitting near the girls. Why?
I think Snape was in love with Lily. You can beat me for that but I think so. I can't remember that they said Lily
was in a special house, maybe I'm wrong, but maybe she was in Slytherin. In my oppinion Harry and Snape's relationship is getting better, but both of them did not realise it. Maybe in the last book the nearly like each other but then I think Snape will die.


"Astrid"






More information about the HPforGrownups archive