OoP - Dumbledore's true sorrow motives

[alexcukier]

No: HPFGUIDX 66806


I, Alex Cukier, wrote:

> > 6) With the information of what happened to The Longbottoms, 
> > Dumbledore confirms that the Potters were V's personal attack.  

Hickengruendler, correctly, appointed

> But the attack of the Longbottoms was after the attack of the 
> Potters. Dumbledore said so in the pensieve scene in GOF. The 
> Longbottoms were attacked, when Voldemort was already gone and 
> everybody thought, they were save.
> 

Yes, but it is not fundamental that Dumbledore confirms that the 
Potters were attacked after Longbottom's atttack. The Longbottom 
could be attacked after th Potters, with no demage to my theory. The 
main idea was that the Ancient Magic used to save Harry made that 
scar on it, too.

But thank you for appoint that minor mistake.

I'd love if anyone else could contribute to analyse other points of 
that.

Alex Cukier, The Brazilian Huge Fan