OOP:McGonagall's cookies (not really a spoiler - I don't think)

emmajess29 cassandre.lamaudite at laposte.net
Sat Jul 5 14:23:15 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 67582

fhm wrote :
[...] why "ginger" biscuits. I research the medicinal properties of 
ginger and found that it has beenused as an antiemetic and FOR PAIN.

my reply :
I've just done my own research, and it seems to me that ginger is 
mainly used against nausea and stomacal pain. But I may be wrong.

fhm wrote :
Which leads me think McGonagal knew about Umbridges use of the pain 
causing pen.

my reply :
I don't think she knew. If she had, I suppose she would have given 
Harry some more "vanishing-pain-biscuits" for the entire week. And 
like others have said, she would have told him why she was feeding 
him with that.
Nevertheless, I prefer the "with biscuits in your mouth you can't 
talk"-theory... It sounds so much more "McGonagall-esque" to me ! ;o)

EmmaJess






More information about the HPforGrownups archive