OOP: Umbridge and Kreacher

Ximena Valdivia xvaldivia at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 5 23:44:39 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 67680

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Ryan Dino" <mrryandino at y...> 
wrote:
> Second:  Is the Order of Phoenix now in trouble now that Black is 
> dead?  They were in trouble even when Black was alive because 
> Kreacher had no loyalty to him, but Kreacher could not disobey a 
> direct order from him.  Now that Black is dead, is he freed or does 
> he go to the Lestranges, to the Malfoys, or to Harry who is his 
> godson?  Harry is not a blood relative (as far as we know) so I 
don't 
> see him becoming Kreacher's master.  If Kreacher is freed or goes 
to 
> Black's cousins, the secrets of the Order are in jeopardy.  How 
much 
> does he know?
> 
> Ryan

I don't think he is free just because Sirius died (sob), when Sirius 
was in Azkaban, Kreacher was all alone in the house following orders 
of the portraits. I don't think he can leave to the LEstranges or to 
the Malfoys and tell them about he order since he does not have 
anyone to tell him to go out (like Sirius did) since he doesn't have 
any master. Also, it's impossible that anyone outside the order can 
find Kreacher since he is inside Grimmauld and according to the book 
the only persons that can find that place are the ones that 
Dumbledore has told them. But in case he can leave, the only thing 
new that can told to the DE and that can put in danger a member of 
the order, is that Snape is part of it. 

Ximena





More information about the HPforGrownups archive