[HPforGrownups] Oh, God, why Sirius????

[Melanie Black]

No: HPFGUIDX 67997

Mariana wrote:
Anyway, I'm so so so sad, I just can't believe she,above all, chose to kill Sirius.  And it's not only the fact that she killed him, it's HOW she did it. I was in complete denial, only being able to confirm it when DD did. I'm still not willing to accept it, I won't, sorry.
I wonder why she didn't write a much more melodramatic death, including Sirius last words to Harry, something like "I'm very proud of you" or " I'll always be with you". That would have made me cry like never before.

My reply: 
There is a part of me that feels that these final words will be told to Harry sometime.  I personally was upset that Remus did not talk to harry about Sirius death.  However I was thinking yesterday and the only consolation that I could find is that Remus is hurting too.  We know he is.  I"m fairly certain that the reason that JKR did not deal with this heart to heart discussion is ithat she was either not ready to write it or not wanted to have a little bit of Sirius left in the next two books.  I personally believe that Sirius kept memmories for Harry.  He either had a pensieve kept or he wrote Harry letters.  The reason I believe this, is Sirius felt a great desire to prove to Harry that he cared for him and we know that Sirius thought of harry the entire time he was in Azkaban.  Perhaps I'm asking for to much.  Perhaps I'm hoping too much.  But I personally believe that Sirius left Harry something to remember him by.  Either from the personal memmories of others or from Sirius
 himself.  
 
~Melanie
 
(Who is still upset that Harry and Sirius did not say "I love you" to eachother).


We shall never forget Sirius Black....long live his memory!  
 
"Wit beyond measure is a man's greatest pleasure" ~Luna Lovegood, OOTP pg. 186.
 
Check out my first latest Fan Fic piece:  
http://www.fanfiction.net/read.php?storyid=1401067 
 
It's called Behind The Veil!




---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! DSL - Now only $29.95 per month!

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]