Some More Potential OoP Flints

[jsmithqwert]

No: HPFGUIDX 68543

>Phyllis: 
> > 2.	In the Room of Requirement, a whistle appears when Harry 
> > wants one.  Why then doesn't a Boggart appear when Harry thinks 
> about 
> > how useful a Boggart would be in helping the DA learn the 
Patronus 
> > Charm?
> Zen:
> I believe someone has stated a theory that the Room can "summon" 
what 
> actually exists in the castle, but not create out of thin air.  If 
> there isn't one hiding in a clock or a closet someplace, then there 
> isn't one in stock, so to speak.
> 
> Phyllis:
> > 5.	There are fifty witches and wizards at Harry's hearing, and 
> > Arthur indicates his belief that this constitutes the entire 
> > Wizengamot.  However, at Karkaroff's hearing in GoF, there were 
> over 
> > 200 witches and wizards in attendance.
> Zen:
> Wouldn't there be many more members of the Wizengamot during a time 
> when the WW is dealing with the fallout of Voldemort, and there are 
> hundreds of DEs to deal with?
> 

Me:

2.  I also think that there are some limitations to what the room can 
summon.  Those things include money (it would be theft) and 
people/beings/living things (i.e. bogarts).

5.  In addition, everyone at Harry's trial votes; therefore, I 
suspect they are all members of the Wizengamot.  At the trials in 
DD's penseive, Crouch specifically asks the jury, aka the Wizengamot, 
to vote, and it does not include everyone in the chamber.

jsmithqwert