Some More Potential OoP Flints

John Gabriel jgabriel66 at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 9 06:06:17 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 68606

>Phyllis: 
>
> 2. In the Room of Requirement, a whistle 
> appears when Harry wants one.  Why then 
> doesn't a Boggart appear when Harry thinks 
> about how useful a Boggart would be in 
> helping the DA learn the Patronus Charm?
>

Maybe objects only, and not beings or 
beasts, can be summoned to the Room of
Requirements? Just a thought, but it 
would make sense. If a boggart can be
summoned, why not one of the professors,
or one of the creatures from the 
Forbidden Forest? One caveat, though:
I would suspect that those beings/beasts 
that *can* be created magically, fairies
for instance, could be summoned or 
created by the Room. Otherwise, only
objects will be provided.

John







More information about the HPforGrownups archive