The Room of Requirement

[dreamzworld_2000]

No: HPFGUIDX 68613

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Beth" <jillily3g at y...> wrote:
> During the DA's first practice, the Dark Detectors are mentioned 
> twice, once when Harry first spies them, and once when Dean asks 
> about them. And while Harry explains that "you don't want to rely 
on 
> them too much," the Foe-glass, at least, revealed Fake!Moody's 
> enemies in GoF. So why don't any of the Dark Detectors go off 
before 
> Dobby comes to warn the DA's of Umbridge's approach?
> 
> Also, if the room merely summons, rather than creates, aren't 
> Flitwick, Pince, et al annoyed when their possession disappear? 
> (Maybe that's what's happening to Luna's stuff--someone has need of 
> it <g>)
> 
> Beth

Well good thought on the part of the room's items but in my opinion, 
i believe that the room simply conjures up whatever things the 
occupant(s) happens to think of at the time. I dont think that the 
room uses any summoning charm, just a simple conjuring charm. Then 
again, how does the room conjure up these things? Doesn't it need to 
use a wand or something similar?

beebee