[HPforGrownups] Musings on discrepancies/anomalies (?)

[Wildean]

No: HPFGUIDX 68912

From: "D.G." <dgwhiteis at hotmail.com>
Subject: [HPforGrownups] Musings on discrepancies/anomalies (?)


>      All in all, it seems that plunging into a Penseive and observing
> someone else's private memories is not a punishable offense, or at
> least has never been defined as one.  Isn't this rather strange?

Agreed.



> 2.  Maybe I'm misunderstanding somethinng -- but according to Snape's
> own memories, he took his exam parchment out of the classroom and
> continued perusing it underneath a tree, as his classmates hung
> around nearby.  How could this be?

Presumably the exam that's handed in is the answers only - you'd get a
printed question sheet/booklet/parchment and just write your answers on
blank parchment, and this parchment is submitted at the end. Although, when
I took my (non-magical) exams, the question section had to be returned as
well.

Wildean