Tom Riddle's mother /NOW ALSO Salazar and DE's...

darrin_burnett bard7696 at aol.com
Thu Jul 10 11:40:00 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 69043

> > > > 
> > And before you argue with me about the "all Slyths are racist 
> fools" thing, be 
> > prepared to show me one that isn't... in canon. Don't give 
> me, "Well, there just 
> > HAS to be one who isn't."
> > 
> > Canon.
> > 

Adam: 

> Can you point out where it is said that "ALL Slyths are racist 
> fools?"  Since we really only know about four or five of them, and 
> only Draco expresses any deep-seeded hatred for "mudbloods," is it 
a fair generalization of the entire house?  Isn't it just as wrong to 
> say that "ALL Slyths are racist fools" as it is to think that 
> all "mudbloods" are worthless?  Both statements are broad 
> generalizations based on very limited information.


All the Slyths we've met so far are proponents of the mudblood 
doctrine. 

Like I said, the answer to my statements on this matter have always 
been, "well, well, there HAS to be one, gosh darned it!"

No, there doesn't. 

This isn't the real world. It is entirely possible that there is 
something in the Slytherin water that creates this little bastards. 

Rather than continually gripe at JKR for perpetuating "the 
stereotype" of the Slytherin, perhaps it's now to the point to start 
looking at why someone who creates rich, well-drawn characters, has 
chosen to do so.

Darrin





More information about the HPforGrownups archive