The Useless Character of Harry Potter

flower_fairy12 flower_fairy12 at yahoo.co.uk
Fri Jul 11 19:26:03 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 69490

"Josephine" <josie421 at h...> wrote:
> Harry Potter is boring.
> Harry Potter is dull.
> Harry Potter never comes around to doing anything.

Oh no, your right, Harry doesn't do *anything* in the books. I love 
the way he stares at a blank wall watching paint dry for 99% of the 
chapters. He just *imagines* Voldemort. 


> In fact, Harry Potter has no function except carrying the whole 
> frickin' story upon his ruddy adolescent shoulders (...)

Hmm...carry the story...let's see...the stories are about Harry, 
aren't they? Maybe JKR should call the books Harry Potter but the 
books are really all about someone called Bill Smith. 


> I mean, think about it. Who makes the Potter books worth reading? 
Not 
> Potter. Potter is a whiny, insecure, mouse-gray sort-of hero. Not 
> complex, but stupid. He knows nothing. I hate him.

Have you read the books? If so, why keep reading if you don't like 
them? 

> Look, instead, at the people surrounding him:...Ginny, who 
matures... 

Pity you don't :)


Rosie






More information about the HPforGrownups archive