Sirius...Voldemort...oh, my goodness.

[Echa Schneider]

No: HPFGUIDX 69868


On Saturday, July 12, 2003, at 09:37 PM, bookraptor11 wrote:

> It would make for a different end to the series.  By bringing Sirius
> back, Harry becomes evil, joins V, and Neville steps in to take the
> Hero's role.

That would be an incredibly shocking and amazing thing from a story 
standpoint, but I don't think I could bear it! I love these characters 
way too much, and if that happened I doubt I could ever appreciate how 
gutsy and shocking JKR was. Instead I would probably just burn all my 
HP books in disgust or something. I think, Donna, that you have just 
raised the bar for terrible things that could happen.

Echa, who is happy to return to the list having just finished OoP and 
also once again inclined to post for the first time in over a year