Harry to skip out on Hogwarts before the end?
hedge2staxy
hodgins at ssi.net
Mon Jul 14 19:53:06 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 70252
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "newdevilry9" <ginaann9 at a...>
wrote:
> What if Fred & George's departure is a way of setting Harry up to
not
> finish all 7 years at Hogwarts? I have to say, as much as I love
> Hogwarts, I wouldn't be opposed to this. Throughout OotP I felt
sort
> of trapped, that there was interesting stuff happening with the
Order
> and not at the school. It certainly seemed that the characters
were
> feeling this to some extent as well. It would be reasonable that
> with the progressing war, something could happen that could even
> cause them all to abandon the school (ok, maybe I'm pushing my
luck,
> but maybe not.) I've posted this before and didn't really hear
> anyone's thoughts on it. Maybe it's just not that deep. I would
> love to hear feedback on this!
>
> NewDev
OK then, here it goes. I can't imagine that JKR, the woman who got
kids reading something thicker than a comic book (thicker than my
phonebook!), would advocate dropping out of school by having Harry
do so. I realize that stopping school after 'O' levels in Britain
is not the same as not finishing high school in the U.S.(more
equivalent to getting a General Equivalency Diploma perhaps?), but it
still just doesn't send the message that I would expect from her.
I think in Book 6, we will see instruction, not only in DADA class,
but also in transfiguration, charms, etc. that is more focused on
how students may have to defend themselves in the future. This will
help to keep the students engaged. It's exciting though. We knew
that Book 5 would have to deal with the covert battle against Voldie
after seeing Fudge's reaction at the end of GoF, but what direction
will JKR go in Book 6. Perhaps, Remus will return and ultimately be
revealed as James Potter a la Swithching Spell?
My 2 cents--Hedgehog
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive