Col. Fubster

[Melinda Leydon]

No: HPFGUIDX 70510

jenny from ravenclaw said:
Okay, I cannot take credit for this idea, but I loved it so I'll put
it out there again.  It could be possible that Harry was not the one
at all who broke Marge's glass in PoA.  It could have been Petunia,
tapping into her own stores of possible abilities, reacting to the
fact that her sister-in-law pretty much referred to Lily as a bitch (I
remember being quite shocked the first time I read that scene).


I've been wondering about this too, and am tending to lean towards the idea
that it might have been Petunia.  Some movie contamination coming, but I'm
really waiting to see if this scene is included in PoA next June.  I know
JKR makes them keep things that are important to the future, and this scene
could easily be cut and just include the one where Marge blows up.  If they
keep it, however, I think would be a further clue that it could be Petunia.

Melinda  (who finds herself thinking of the movie a lot as that is the next
target date to focus on!  LOL!  PoA is still my favorite and they better not
mess it up on me)