Remus = James? NOT

[danielmorgan322]

No: HPFGUIDX 70881

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, <lmbolland at e...> wrote:
> > I have quick question.  If James and Remus had switched wouldn't 
he 
> > had know that Peter was the Secret Keeper and not Sirius.  He 
would 
> > have known that Peter betrayed them and not Sirius.
> > 
> Then Lauri said:

> Excellent point. I think OOP settled the whole James=Remus  theory. 
(Which I just didn't buy, as a parent - who would abandon his 
wife/child when they're sought by the most dangerous wizard of all 
time??)   
> 
> To your point - If they changed secret keepers *before* James & 
Remus did the switching spell - why?  The reason for changing secret 
keepers (from Sirius to the less obvious choice of Peter) was (I 
assume - am I wrong?) because James & Sirius suspected Remus was the 
traitor.  If they changed secret keepers *after* doing the switching 
spell, it would have been Remus & Sirius who did the deciding, 
leaving James out of the decision. (What point?)
> 
> Lauri

ME:

The whole Lupin is James argument has always been pointless to me, 
JKR explicitly stated that we will never see James Or Lilly alive 
again. I think thats a pretty solid reason to think that James is NOT 
Remus.

Morgan