[HPforGrownups] Good Slytherin - Plus an old debate

[Random]

No: HPFGUIDX 71355


On Thursday, Jul 17, 2003, at 19:54 America/Indianapolis, Steve wrote:

> bboy_mn responds:
> See, this is the root of the problem between the opposing sides on
> this issue. Slytherin hadn't won the House Cup, they were only in the
> lead and expected to win. Dumbledore is well within his rights and
> well with in the rules to award last minute points. So, if Snape can
> dock 50 points (or 20 or 10) for minor infraction, then certainly
> Dumbledore can award 50 points for extreme acts of selflessness and
> courage, even if it wasn't tempered with the best of wisdom.

Actually, they had won, they'd been told in front of the whole school 
that they won, "but WAIT!"

This is how i remember it, i've searched all over the house and can't 
locate my copy of the book.

--Random832