Snape and purity of blood
oh have faith
rshuson80 at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 19 13:45:13 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 71604
Valky says:
> Apart from the *perhaps* 'fleeting' indiscretion against Lily in
the
> pensieve when Snape was a young man, there has been no direct
> implication of prejudice against blood by Snape in the books, as I
> recall it.
> I read into it that he must maintain a professionalism a a
teacher,
> as well. So I can not say for sure that he has no prejudice
existing
> in him as an adult.
>
> Valky
I can't imagine that he would work so hard for the Order if he had
any secret sympathies for what the DEs stand for myself - I can
imagine a dislike of violence might make him not want to work *for*
them, but not to so actively oppose them - unless he knew he
couldn't possibly get out once he was in without the protection of
the one wizard even Voldemort fears, and a bit of hard graft is the
price Dumbledore asked.
He seems to just about hate everybody equally, as well, regardless
of breeding. His early racist tendencies -calling Lily a mudblood
for eg- could be a clue as to his change of heart. Maybe he heard
such language at home all the time, and so was bound to parrot it
when he felt defensive - but his father seems hardly a lovable man,
so maybe Snape later rebelled against his shouty-bastardness and all
his values. Besides, he's a bright enough lad to figure these
things out for himself - he hates James Potter and Sirius Black more
than anyone, and they're both purebloods. Maybe he has them to
thank for the realisation that blood doesn't really count for much.
(and of course, just because he flared up at Lily in a defensive
moment, doesn't mean he didn't later feel bad about alienating the
one person who stuck up for him. Like I said, he's a clever fella,
he could probably figure it out!)
Faith's Girl
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive