Dumbledore is Hedwig
jakedjensen
jakejensen at hotmail.com
Sat Jul 19 17:27:32 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 71646
Todd wrote:
> ***OOP spoiler***
>
> Interesting theory. However, I think a major problem is the fact
> that Hedwig is with Harry at the Dursleys' while Dumbledore is
> running around the Ministry trying to straighten out Harry's
> expulsion over using magic on the dementors. If DD IS Hedwig, he
> can't be in two places at once--even JKR doesn't mess with that law
> of physics without timetravel.
>
> On a related note, are we really to expect that while Hedwig is
> locked in Harry's room all summer, DD is as well? Where does he
> find the time to hire new DADA teachers?
>
> I would find it much more possible for there to be some link
between Hedwig and DD, but not for them to be the same person. >>>
Another good point. However, for everyone having trouble with how
Dumbledore can be Hedwig because of the time issues remember that
Hedwig dissapears for long periods of time during the summers. Also,
since Dumbledore can apparate he could take the letters from Harry
and just apparate to the place he needed to deliver them too
(whenever he liked...thus saving time). Hedwig tends to be MIA quite
a bit. This doesn't prove anything, but it does allow for the
possibility.
Also, consider the following language from the books:
****SPOILERS****
In OotP, Minerva said that Albus got the new and then quickly flew to
the MoM (he could use a broom..but why not apparate)?
Dumbledore tells Hermoine once (can't remember which book) that he
passed her delivery owl in the air. An interesting thing to do.
Dumbledore wears half moon spectacles. Not sure what this
means...but moons...owls.
Jake
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive