Is DD spying through the Choc frog cards?

[davidbartmess]

No: HPFGUIDX 71692

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "greatelderone" 

> But the frog cards also seem to have a mind of their own since 
they 
> can disappear from the cards when they feel like it which just 
> reinforces the idea that Dumbledore is using them to spy on the 
trio.


I've been thinking about DD using the Choc. Frog cards to spy on 
Harry too, the only problem I have with it is that Harry probably 
doesn't carry the chocolate frog cards with him all the time, and 
Dumbledore seem to be aware of almost all of Harry's actions (or at 
least quite a few of them).  For example In OOTP Harry is about to 
be thrown out by Uncle Dursley, and just then Aunt Petunia gets a 
Howler from DD.  Later Harry is about to flee from 12 Grimmwauld 
place and just then Phineas Nigellus appears in his painting with a 
message from DD, telling him to stay there. There are numerous other 
examples all through all 5 books of DD somehow being aware of what's 
going on with Harry.  

Also, unless Harry's Dumbledore card is on top of the stack, and 
not covered by any other object, DD still couldn't see what 
was going on.  Harry would practically have to have his Dumbledore 
Choc. Frog card pinned to his robe for this to work!  :-)

David Bartmess