Is DD spying through the Choc frog cards?
scoutmom21113
navarro198 at hotmail.com
Sat Jul 19 22:53:17 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 71704
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, CareALotsClouds at a... wrote:
> Someone raised this the other day, and whilst it makes sense, in
book 5 Bill
> joked that DD asked not to be taken off the cards - this may be a
subtle clue,
> but isnt it only paintings with minds of their own? I mean, Colin
has a
> photo of Harry but Harry doesnt see everything that Colin does when
Colin has it
> with him or whatever. The cards dont talk or anything so Im
wondering how
> Dumbledore does do this if its the case with his cards.
>
I think that may be a clue. If he is using the cards, he may not be
watching through only the cards that Harry has, but also cards any
student is carrying - hearing what they are saying. We know he has
powers that others know not :-)
Another possibility that I've thought about is his watch. It is
mentioned in the first chapter of SS, and again during the fight at
the Ministry. In SS it is described has having 12 hands and planets
revolving around the outside where the numbers would be. It sounds a
bit like the Weasley's clock, but I'm not sure how the planets fit
in. Divination a la the centaurs maybe?
Ravenclaw Bookworm
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive