Subject: Ginny's future in Quidditch, and a little about Ron's "visions"

[Arya]

No: HPFGUIDX 72324

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "flying_meese" 
<original_gt at y...> wrote:
> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Kathryn Cawte" <kcawte at b...> 
> wrote:
> > Plus I'm not sure the Seeker is in the best position to be 
> captain. The
> > Captain should be able to watch what is going on in the gae, make
> > adjustments to the strategy if necessary and note what they did 
> right/wrong
> > for future games. The Seeker is paying attention to one thing 
> only - the
> > snitch. I doubt Harry usually knows who did what during a game.
> > 
> > K
> 
> I was all ready to go into my speil about Harry being made captain. 
> For I don't believe that anything that Umbridge did will be held 
> against anyone. I would imagine that McG is responsible for 
> appointing the captain as the Griffyndor head and I can't see her 
> letting Harry's ban by Umbridge affect his captaincy. But Kathryn's 
> post makes alot of sense in that with Harry's position 
requirements, 
> being a captain (which also seems to involve coaching duties), 
> would, detract from his focus.
> 
> FM


We know that MCGonagall is INDEED the one who appoints captaincy 
because Angelina says so ("McGonagall just told me I am 
Captain...").  Also, to counterpoint that a Seeker can't be a Captain-
-Cedric Diggory was Hufflepuff's 'new Seeker and Captain'.