Purebloods (was Re: flowers)
oh have faith
rshuson80 at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 22 17:32:52 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 72346
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Zeynep Oner <kozmoz4 at y...>
wrote:
>
> Remember in CoS, Draco says with relish 'the last
> time, a mudblood died'. So, since he knows everything
> other than some crucial details, about the last time,
> that should be true, meaning Myrtle is muggle-born.
>
> I know that she died a fifty years ago, but how could
> she, being dead, have descendants? Also she was a
> witch in a line of muggles, how can her descendants be
> pureblood?
>
> Oh or do you mean ancestors instead of descendants?
> But still...
>
Wait, don't confuse me... I'm about to say something that needs
thinking about!
Okay, I know that in the WW we have these old far-back-as-the-dawn-
of-time Pureblood families, like the Blacks and the Malfoys, but in
my understanding, all it requires to be a pureblood is to have a
wizard and a witch as parents. I know Harry is referred to in CoS
and again in OOP as a half-blood, despite him having two magical
parents, because one was muggle-born. But many generations does
this "muggleborn" taint last? I know the nazi-esque DEs would
probably say any drop of muggle blood is enough to taint the whole
line - but what about in the more moderate wizarding world? If
Harry had kids with a witch, and they had kids with a witch etc, how
many generations would it be before they were generally understood
to be purebloods?
So, Myrtle's pureblood descendants - presumably she wasn't a teenage
mother, so they wouldn't be direct descendants, but let's say she
had a cousin who was also a witch who married a wizard who had kids
etc etc and a little bit down the line there'd be kids who could be
described as pure-blooded by everyone who didn't have a real fetish
for eugenics... right?
So, as a counter to a few people on this board who've said all pure-
blooded characters must be related to each other in some way, due to
inbreeding - hence Harry must somehow be related to Sirius though
his pureblood father- maybe not. Maybe you can still be a pureblood
with muggle ancestors.
This is just speculation, of course. See, I'd've described Harry
himself as a pureblood, except it says not in canon. Maybe his kids
would be quarter-bloods. And then eighth-bloods! And then... well,
you get the picture!
^_^ Faith's Girl
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive