Number of Years Teaching at Hogwarts -- ?Significance
ellejir
eberte at vaeye.com
Tue Jul 22 22:58:39 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 72436
I was listening again to the audiotape today and was struck by how
much detail there is in the passages in which Umbridge interviews the
teachers about their positions at Hogwarts. She makes a point of
asking each teacher how long they have been at Hogwarts.
Trelawney said 16 years--significant obviously because of the
prophesy she made 16 years before. Dumbledore clearly wanted to
protect her (and the prophesy--possibly in her memory) from Lord V
and the DEs, so he kept her at Hogwarts despite her minimal skills as
a teacher.
Snape said 14 years--so he apparently came to Hogwarts around the
time or immediately after Lord V's attack on Harry and his family.
This timing seems very significant. Do you think that he was on the
side of the DEs or acting as a spy already for the Order at the time
of Harry's attack? Do you think that he might have had anything to
do with Voldemort's choice of Harry and the Potters (vs. Neville and
the Longbottoms) as the ones to attack??? That could explain some of
his conflicted feelings about Harry.
McGonnagal said something like 38 years (sorry, I don't have the book
here). Does this just indicate that she is an "old-timer", or does
that number have other significance?
Elle
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive