Why was Hermione at Grimmauld?

skyelarke2003 skyelarke2003 at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 23 17:43:14 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 72625


> sorry to be nitpicky, but isn't 'skiing not my thing' ehrmione's 
> excuse for turning up at Christmas, when Harry's thinks everyone 
> blames him for Mr Weasley being attacked?  
> 
> She never explains why she's been there all summer holidays, 
helping 
> clean the house.  I  do think the theory about her being better 
> protected has something in it - but if I  were her parents I'd 
wonder 
> why I never saw my daughter for more than a day ayear!  she's never 
> there at Christmas, was barely there of the summer holidays and no 
> one leaves at easter.

I agree with you here...there really is no good explanation for why 
she was at Grimmauld Place all summer.  For the purpose of the story 
she HAS to be there during the summer..but in "reality" I doubt her 
muggle parents would allow their daughter to spend so much time away 
from them than is absolutely necessary.  We know next to nil about 
Hermione's parents.  They were in Diagon Alley in "Chamber of 
Secrets", but they remain insignificant figures.  I think maybe for 
the sake of the story ark, JKR had her at Grimmauld  place.  There 
are certain aspects of the stories that cannot always be fleshed out 
in a logical way, and sometimes we just have to leave them like that. 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive