Order of the Phoenix

[scooting2win]

No: HPFGUIDX 72972

scooting2win wrote:

>   <<<snip>Now, my second question is rather silly, but I still 
don't agree 
>   with what was said about it. I think that Harry should have seen 
the 
>   horses at the end of his fourth year, he was fully aware and 
>   understood that Cedric was dead. He had gone to the feast and 
>   understood that Cedric was dead when he saw the black in honor 
of 
>   Cedric. Someone who does not have an understanding that Cedric 
was 
>   dead would not have been so afflicted by the feast in itself.  
any 
>   thoughts?


Dawn wrote:
 
>   Did Harry (or anyone else, for that matter) use the carriages at 
the end of the year?  When Harry gets out of the express at the 
start of his 4th (academic) year, it is the first time he has seen 
them.  As he had previously arrived by boat, car and Knight bus, it 
would seem that the carriages are only laid on at the start of the 
year, not the end, so Harry didn't see the thestrals until the start 
of his 5th year.
> 

Me, no the carraiges are used at the end of the year. Harry never 
went to Hogsmeade on the knights bus. it's always been the 
carraiges. and at the end of the fourth year they definately went by 
carraige. 

Scooting2Win