Evans family

[Allison Hill]

No: HPFGUIDX 72975

>From:  "mtwelovett" <mbush at l...

>I don't know, but I think there is a
>"perception" thing at play here for some reason...

Me (Belsum):
I agree 100% with this.  I still haven't found anything that explicitly 
denies the possibility.  Sure, the interpretations I'm making may be obtuse, 
but logically they are reasonable ones, however improbable.

>I stil think that it is possible for
>people in the WW to make similar assumptions. If Lily grew up in a
>seemingly Muggle house, for whatever reason, wouldn't there be wizards
>that assume that she then was a "moodblood?"

Me (Belsum):
I think this is very likely.  Or, what if her mother or father was a squib?  
Would she still be Muggle-born?  Neville says that his gran thought he was 
"all-Muggle" before showing magical ability so how clear is the distinction? 
  Harry calls his mother Muggle-born this while in the Chamber with Tom 
Riddle.  But did anyone tell him?  I feel like he's making the same 
assumptions.  "The Dursleys had always forbidden questions about his 
wizarding relatives."  (CoS:  The Dueling Club)  He knows nothing about his 
family.

Basicly, who have we
>heard refer to Lily as a moodblood or of Muggle Parentage.. or rather
>who have we not heard say these things? (Dumbledore -- for one, I
>don't recall him ever making mention of Lily having Muggle Parents. If
>anyone knows otherwise, I'll gladly give up.)


Me (Belsum):
Excellent point!  I keep scanning through the books looking for something 
completely irrefutable but I haven't yet been able to satisfy myself.
Belsum

_________________________________________________________________
MSN 8 with e-mail virus protection service: 2 months FREE*  
http://join.msn.com/?page=features/virus