Mudblood
corinthum
kkearney at students.miami.edu
Fri Jul 25 03:49:43 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 72991
RocketGranny asked:
> Where in cannon does it say that MUDBLOOD means BOTH parents are
> muggles? And if you're a half-blood: one magical parent and one
> muggle parent ... wouldn't this qualify you for the (derogatory)
> mudblood label?
"'Mudblood's a really foul name for someone who is Muggle-born-- you
know, non-magic parents....'" (CoS p. 115 US paperback).
I'd say the use of the plural here seems to indicate that Muggle-born
is only used when both parents are Muggles, and that the term mudblood
is used almost exclusively to insult Muggle-borns.
However, you have to keep in mind that "Mudblood" is not a precisely
defined scientific term. It's a highly offensive, very derogatory
slur, used only by people who feel ancestry is important in
determining a person's character.
The extent to which the term can be applied depends on the level of
hatred and ingnorance of the user. The die-hard pureblood supporters,
like Bellatrix Lestrange and the Malfoys, would probably say it
applies to anyone who is not 100% pureblood, although they seem to use
it most often with Muggle-borns. However, I'm sure there are some
witches and wizards out there who don't really believe in pureblood
superiority, but are disgusted by/angered by/simply disdainful of
Muggles, and this dislike extends as far as their using a slur when
angered or frustrated by a Muggle-born witch or wizard.
The reason the term "mudblood" is so vague is that it really has no
purpose. It doesn't indicate anything measurable about a witch or
wizard. It's like trying to define the n-word. Is there a certain
number of black ancestors required before the term can be used? Of
course not. It's a horribly offensive term used by ignorant people to
indicate a nonexistent flaw in another person. Hardly quantifyable.
The term half-blood is pretty all-encompassing because it is equally
meaningless. It only indicates a lack of another meaningless stereotype.
So, my conclusion:
In the eyes of a normal, intelligent witch or wizard:
pureblood = both parents magical, regardless of other ancestors
half-blood = one parent magical, on parent Muggle
Muggle-born = both parents Muggles
In the eyes of the ignorant, discriminating witch or wizard:
pureblood = no Muggle anywhere in ancestry
Muggle-born = both parents Muggles
half-blood = anything else
Mudblood = slur for non-purebloods, usually used on Muggle-borns
-Corinth
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive