Harry's Boggart

kfc4588 kfc4588 at yahoo.com
Sun Jul 27 13:00:34 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 73443

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Jim Ferer" <jferer at y...> 
wrote:
> Buttercup:I think Harry's boggart will be seeing Sirius fall
> through the veil over and over again, knowing that he
> wasn't able to save him."
> 
> Good thought, and you're right, I believe.  My tongue was somewhat 
in
> my cheek about Draco's boggart being Harry, but Jenny is right, 
Harry
> loathes Umbridge more than fears her.
> 
> A Boggart, though, takes the shape of an object, a thing, that a 
human
> fears most, so what Harry would see is Sirius's body or the Door of
> the Dead (how's that for a name?), not the scene of Sirius's death,
> just as Mrs. Weasley saw her loved ones dead, not them dying 
horribly.
>  IOW, boggarts don't put on plays.


i think it is more likley that harry will see the door of the dead 
because that is something to fear- seeing sirius dead may have been 
his boggart before sirius actually died- but now that he is dead i 
think he fears the archway/veil thing way more than he fears seeing 
sirius dead, because its already happpened. Am i making any sense 
here?
well thats just IMO
-Casey
> 
> Jim





More information about the HPforGrownups archive