What Did DiaryTom Know & When Did He Know It?
Charlie Moody
shaman at mac.com
Mon Jul 28 02:14:03 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 73549
In CoS, Riddle makes reference to Harry's 'mud-blood mother'; how does
he know? DiaryTom was shut up in a notebook for 50 years - and
arguably knew nothing about James or Lily, neither of whom would have
been born during DiaryTom's time @ Hogwarts.
If all his information about Harry comes from Ginny Weasley, how does
SHE come to cough up that particular chestnut? And, if Ginny knows,
how could Harry's best friend & resident expert on the WizardWorld (and
Ginny's brother) have failed to mention that Harry's mother was
Muggle-born, ESPECIALLY in light of Harry's ignorance of the term
'mudblood' earlier in the book?
I'll be going back & re-reading all 5 soon (and I'll be taking notes,
you may be sure!), but pending that: is there a canonical source for
the assertion that Lily is Muggle-born (other than Petunia's spiteful &
self-serving remarks early in HP+tPS)? Any basis for believing that
DiaryTom had access to info about Harry's family beyond Ginny?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive