Questions.

[chopsy2001]

No: HPFGUIDX 73632

Just a couple of quick questions I'd like you to consider and show me 
where I'm going wrong.

1) In the first chapter of GoF we learn that Tom Riddle killed his 
parents and yet there were actually 3 Riddles who had died "who all 
looked as though they had been frightened to death". Well who is the 
third Riddle that was killed. The young one seems so much as if it 
was Tom himself. The only thing I ever came up with was that Tom was 
faking his death.

2) In PS/SS Snape knows most of the time what Quirrel is up to. Yet 
why does he not tell Dumbledore? Surely that would be the most 
sensible thing to do? Instead of trying to solve it himself.

3) In GoF Harry uses the portkey to get back to hogwarts. And yet 
shouldn't this be used only at a PRE-DESTINED time. Also why didn't 
Crouch/Moody simply transfer Harry's pillow into a portkey instead of 
going through the rigmarole of setting up the triwizard tournament.

More later...

Will.