A mole in the order? was: Sirius - who is right?
Arya
jdq53562 at aol.com
Mon Jul 28 21:56:37 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 73721
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Carolin Mönkemeyer
<shokoono at g...> wrote:
>
> > now me: I haven't until now actually paid much creedence to any of
> > the evil Lupin theories, however, now that I think about the
> > possibility of Sirius being poisoned, Lupin seems to me to be the
> > likeliest candidate. Well, maybe likeliest isn't the right word,
but
> > I am certainly suspicious; anyone who would be poisoning Sirius
would
> > most likely be doing it at regular intervals, right? Well, if
Lupin
> > lives with Sirius, he has a good excuse to be around Sirius often
> > enough to continue feeding him the poison.
> >
> > that's really all the evidence that I have to back me up, but
still,
> > I think its worth considering.
> >
> Me:
> What about Kreacher? I know he has to obay Sirius but Dobby had to
obay his
> master Mr Malfoy aswell AND HE DIDN'T !!!!! It was him who didn't
want
> Harry to go back to school. We know from OoP that Kreacher wasn't
fond of
> Sirius in any way so he could have refused to serving him just the
same way
> Dobby did...
>
> Yours Finchen
Molly was also there and doing all the cooking. In fact, she may
have been sending over food for even when she wasn't staying there.
She may have been umnder imperious (Ron certainly had little ability
to fight off that curse, perhaps she would be weak there as well) or--
OR!!!!--maybe Snape gave Molly some "herbs" for cooking that when
mixed, say with Sirius's fav food/drink, worked to make an effect of
hotheadness and recklessnes. There is SOMETHING with the potions
Harry was reading about and Sirius's behavior. It IS something, I am
sure. Just what......
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive