if Harry survives

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 74072

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Dan Feeney" 
<darkthirty at s...> wrote:
>Also, SS lied to HP 
 directly in these so-called lessons, lied straight out. He told HP 
 there was nothing that concerned him in the DoM. You can 
justify SS's  lying all you want, the point is, he lied, apparently
for 
the first  time, to anyone in the books, with the exception of his 
work for the  OOP. People on the list shrug this off, or come up 
with lame excuses.  But SS lies to HP once in the books, directly, 
by telling him that nothing in the DoM concerns him.<

Er, that's not quite what SS says. He says "There are many 
things in the Department of Mysteries...none of which concern 
you." That does not eliminate the possibility that there are other 
things in the DoM which do concern Harry. Typical Rowling 
doublespeak.

Pippin