argh was Re: Intrinsically Good magic, and motives over ends (Fwd from OTC)

[Amy Z]

No: HPFGUIDX 59303

I wrote, incompletely,

> Or does it?  Dumbledore says it doesn't.  He stands up for the 
> Kantian view, one might say:  save Pettigrew because it's the right 
> thing to do, and let the results fall where they may.  One thing's 
> sure, and that is that the intertwining is so complex that 

even if we are Seers, we can never know all the results of our 
actions.

Amy Z
posting half-finished remarks since 1998
and btw, Pickle Jimmy, the Chinese tale you told is one of my 
favorits--no surprise there

--------------------------
The place to be after OoP!
Nimbus-2003
www.hp2003.org