James an Auror? and Link to Interview on Clearing Hagrid's Name
finwitch
finwitch at yahoo.com
Thu Jun 5 17:14:34 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 59383
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Peggy wrote:
>
> Do we actually know that who he heard was James? I know Harry
> believes it was James, but Lupin seemed suprised that Harry thought
> that he heard Jame's voice. He believed the voice that he heard
> telling Lily to take Harry and run was his father's, but we don't
> know if it was.
>
> Harry heard Jame's voice in the grave yard sceen, after he came out
> of the wand. Though there was nothing said about his voice. There
> was no comaprison made.
>
> It could have been James who told Lily to go, but I don't think we
> can say that for certain.
You can never be 100% certain about anything in fantasy. Lupin's
surprise - well, that Harry _remembers_ things from so far in his
past, that he heard anything at all... Or that he _heard_ him, but
didn't see? Or just Harry telling him what he goes trough when
dementors come near him?
I think Harry's right and it _is_ his father...
-- Finwitch
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive