The hand of Wormtail, the blood of Harry, and that famous gleam...
Mike Pachuta
mpachuta at hotmail.com
Wed Jun 11 00:01:40 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 59924
In my final read of GoF before OotP is released, I came across a small
passage that I had not noticed before. I'm sure others have noticed it, and
I think I may have overlooked a post that might have addressed this before.
If anyone has a link to a thread on this particular topic, let me know....
Here goes:
GoF, US Hardcover, p. 695-696: "When Harry told of Wormtail peircing his arm
with the dagger, however, Sirius let out a vehement exclamation and
Dumbledore stood up so quickly that Harry started. Dumbledore walked around
his desk and told Harry to stretch out his arm. Harry showed them both the
place where his robes were torn and the cut beneath them."
Next comes that famous gleam in Dumbledore's eyes. Now, I know this has
been discussed until everyone on the list turned blue in the face BUT, I
have a new opinion on this...
What if the gleam is not because Voldemort now has "inherited" Wormtail's
lifedebt to Harry? What if the gleam is because Voldemort has actually
inherited from Harry's blood? Again, the gleam come right after Harry shows
off the cut on his arm, not after Harry speaks about Wormtail's sacrifice.
Here's my story, and I'm stickin' to it: Voldemort has reincarnated, but
he's more flawed than a lot of people know. Many know about the lifedebt,
but what happens when someone is reincarnated using flesh from one person
and blood from a person the first is indebted to?
Voldemort has a lifedebt not only to Harry, but also to himself.
Is that possible? Yes - if he gets into a duel or a situation where he has
to defend himself from getting killed, he will have to do what is necessary
to protect himself. In order to do that, he may get into a situation where
his only option is to join the good side. That could potentially be the
only way he can save his own life.
Again, if this has been discussed before, I apologize. I'm just looking for
some feedback, so if someone could provide me with a link to a past thread,
that'd be awesome!
Thanks, y'all!
mikie p - who also thinks that the central conflict in OotP will not involve
Voldemort, but rather between those who believe he has risen again and those
who don't.
_________________________________________________________________
Help STOP SPAM with the new MSN 8 and get 2 months FREE*
http://join.msn.com/?page=features/junkmail
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive