OOP: What is Dumbledore going to tell Harry?

Brooke brookeshanks at mugglenet.com
Wed Jun 11 19:27:15 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 60031

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "blind_nil_date" <Bratschen-
Spieler at c...> wrote:
> I can't imagine that JKR let that tidbit from OOP out as a 
> premonition of full disclosure. She likes to tease, taunt, and give 
> partial truths. Therefore, I think that Dumbledore will begin to 
tell 
> Harry everything, but they will be interrupted and we will not find 
> out all. We'll find out a little, but not everything. It would 
> certainly be in her style.
> 
> 
> "Blind nil date"

I agree with you.  But I think that rather than being interrupted, 
Dumbledore will tell everything Harry that he knows... but I am not 
convinced that Dumbledore knows EVERYTHING.  Remember how James & 
Sirius were able to hide that they had become animagi from 
Dumbledore?  Plus, Dumbledore did not know that Peter & Sirius had 
switched as secret keeper, right?  (er... I could be wrong about that 
one, I am forgeting canon all of a sudden!)  I think there are things 
in the past, especially concerning the night the potters were killed, 
that only one or two people may know the whole truth about.  I think 
the big questions are WHO knows the truth and WHY has it been kept a 
secret for so long??  

Brooke  






More information about the HPforGrownups archive