Voldemort's Names
honeycakehorse03
honeycakehorse03 at hotmail.com
Thu Jun 12 14:04:40 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 60117
We know that language can be a powerful weapon and Dumbledore shows
in every book again that you can make people believe or disbelieve
something only based on your wording.
We all noticed that Voldemort is called different things in the
books, from Lord Voldemort, to only Voldemort, to You-Know-Who, to
He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named, to the Dark Lord.
I looked through the books and tried to determine if the name you
use for Voldemort has any parallels with your opinions about him or
how you feel about him.
So far my basic findings are:
You-Know-Who is what he is called by almost everybody. Mainly the
normal people on the street (Madam Rosmerta, Bagman, Rita Skeeter,
the Weasleys, Hagrid) but also Professor McGonagall, Minister Fudge
and Harry (but that only out of consideration for others).
The names Voldemort and Lord Voldemort are pretty much
interchangeable between the people who use them with the exception
of Voldemort and Tom Riddle himself who always says Lord Voldemort.
Those people are mainly Dumbledore, Remus, Sirius and Harry, but on
occasion also
Lord Voldemort: Quirrell, Crouch Sr. (trial), Fudge,
Voldemort: Peter and Crouch Jr. and McGonagall (forced).
The Dark Lord is mainly used with supporters of Voldemort or people
who are close to supporters of him. Namely: Crouch Sr., Karkaroff,
woman at the trial (Mrs. Lestrange?), Snape, Draco, Dobby, Lucius,
Tom Riddle. It's interesting to see that this name is also mentioned
by Ernie Macmillan, Trelawney and in the Valentine Harry receives
(Ginny?).
He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named is used by Rita Skeeter, Karkaroff, Crouch
Sr.,Dobby (and consequently once be Harry), Trelawney and Pettigrew.
>From my PoV He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named is used by people who are very
intimidated by Voldemort or in public writings (Skeeter article).
I especially want to have a look at Trelawney and Dumbledore in this
post as they seem to be the most interesting to me.
Dumbledore always calls Voldemort by his name, as does Harry, but
Dumbledore says more often than not Lord Voldemort instead of
Voldemort which IMO shows that
a) either Voldemort is really a Lord or
b) that Dumbledore has a certain respect for Voldemort (which
doesn't necessarily bad as it shows that he doesn't underestimate
him.)
On the other hand there is Trelawney who uses Dark Lord mainly in
her vision in PoA but afterwards also uses He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named.
And when we look at the list of people who say Dark Lord, I think
Trelawney is going to turn out to be a supporter of Voldemort.
Any other thoughts?
Sabrina
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive