Children of Death Eaters
jodel at aol.com
jodel at aol.com
Fri Jun 13 21:19:05 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 60336
Pen points out:
<< It may be that there is some dark reason why Death Eaters were requested
to produce sons who would be contemporary with Harry Potter, Ron Weasley and
Neville Longbottom, but we've yet to be given canon evidence for it. But as
for it being a coincidence that Malfoy and his sidekicks are the same age - not
really. There are probably plenty of other children of DEs who are not the
same age as Harry. We just haven't been told about them. >>
And we may just be looking at this issue from the wrong end, too. Pettigrew
had been spying "for a year" according to Sirius Black's Azkaban recollections.
That would have had him taking up that role just about the time Harry was
born.
Pettigrew's defence was "what could be gained by resisting him?" (an
unpopular perception, but not a mysterious one). This was Peter's interpretation of
the direction of the inevitable a full year before Voldemort's eventual defeat.
IF we put these two pieces of info together, it begins to look as if the rise
of Lord Voldemort had *already* passed a critical level some time before he
was unexpectedly brought down. It was SAFE for the DEs to start raising
families. It was *welcomed* that his supporters should be reproducing a new
generation of followers for the victorius Dark Lord. The battle was all over but the
shouting. The new order was assured.
It is not so surprising that there should be four children from families with
DE connections in Harry's year at Hogwarts (Malfoy, Crabbe, Goyle and Nott.
Harry has not remembered Nott yet -- or we have not had this pointed out to us
yet -- but the reader has noticed it) but that there are not more of them.
That the three children Harry *has* noticed are all boys is probably not all that
relevant. Three out of three is not beyond the reach of random occurance when
the outcome has to be a choice between only two possible results.
-JOdel
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive