125 voices are book 4 only (not all four together)

[Hollydaze]

No: HPFGUIDX 60463

Hollydaze wrote:
> > > The reason that the 125 can't be all four books is because in total
> > > there are at least 221 DIFFERENT voices total (all four together) in
> > > fact there are 144 in the first 3 books alone, although I'm not going
> > > to list all 221 (or 144 here) unless anyone REALLY wants me to. :) I
> > > can't say there are definitely 221 in all four books because I don't
> > > know how many voices there are supposed to be in book 1, 2 and 3 so I
> > > don't definitely know that I've found all of them so there could very
> > > well be even more.


(KarenLyall666) wrote:
>
> > You do realise if this list is correct there are actually 126 voices,
> > don't you?...
> >
> > You left out HERMIONE!!!  She is in the book she does speak - and you
> > forgot about her!  Shame on you...
>

Izaskun
> Well, perhaps we can discard the Ireland Rosette (nº 54). It's a voice, to
> be sure, but not a character. So, 125 speaking characters after all.


Yes, it's not a character but they didn't say 125 characters, they said 125 voices. That means you don't have to be a named character or even a human/living character, you just need to speak (hence Crabbe and Goyle, despite being in all 4 books are only voices in one of them - CoS) and have a different voice to anyone else. It said Jim Dale does 125 voices but I'm beginning to wonder if perhaps they rounded it. Does anyone have the time to go through and check the actual US audio tapes?
HOLLYDAZE!!!
(Who's sorry to reply to this a bit late but has been away for 2 days)

"No one's going to try and kill you until we've sorted a few things out," said Lupin.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]