[HPforGrownups] I have a theory

[fridwulfa]

No: HPFGUIDX 60882

Tasha wrote:


> Sorry if you get this more than once....
> I have a theory and dont hate me for it.
> I think Harry and Hermione are twins and that Dumbledore and Lupin
> and Sirius are keeping this from Harry and Hermione so Voldemort wont
> go after her as well. I think when before there parents were killed I
> think the Potters seceretly placed Hermione with muggle parents so
> Voldemort wouldnt go looking for her and try to kill her. They told
> the Grangers about their stituation and the Grangers agreed to take
> her as their daughter and that she must never knew the truth until
> Voldemort is utterly destroyed. The Potters then told Dumbledore and
> Lupin and Sirius but not Pettigrew because he wasnt around a lot and
> told them to keep it a secret.
> They look so much a like and they think a lot like each other and
> they know what the other is thinking. That is why they care about
> each other so much because they are brother and sister.
> Thats my theory so dont get mad at me....
>

Me (Izaskun)
A bit "Star-wars-luke-you-have-a-sister", don't you think??? Anyway, this
theory has already been discussed. Canon doesn't support it. Harry and
Hermione's birthdays are not even the same day.

Cheers, Izaskun