How smart is Peter?

[mongo62aa]

No: HPFGUIDX 60936

Sadi:

I have been thinking about Peter. I don't think he is as weak as we 
might think. In book three we learn he was able to become an 
Animagus. True he needed help but he was able to master the spell. 
When he went into hiding he was able to kill 13 people with one 
spell. He also was smart enough to hide out at the Weasley's. Who 
knows what he heard? I do not think he was as smart as James and the 
others. We have many places that others say he is weak. Any thoughts 
on this?

Me (Bill):

I have always thought that Pettigrew is a much more powerful wizard 
than he is given credit for.  We know only a few things for certain 
about him, (and no, I do not include former accociate's opinions of 
him in that list) and all of them indicate a considerably capable 
wizard.

1) He became an animagus.  Even if he received help, this is still 
something that few witches or wizards can do.

2) He cast a spell that killed 13 people at once, while 
simultaniously cutting off his own finger and changing into his 
animagus form.  This show considerable magical talent, and a lot of 
willpower.

3) He resurrected the Dark Lord, while cutting off his own hand 
partway through the ritual.  Again, this shows great magical ability 
and willpower.

I know that a lot of people really dislike him, as do I, but it 
cannot be denied, in my opinion, that he is one of the top wizards 
of his generation, even if he plays for the wrong team.

Bill