New Favorite in the Series?
gopotter2004
gopotter2004 at yahoo.com
Mon Jun 23 03:37:09 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 61771
Tamara wrote:
> > I must say, this book has come in a clean second for my favorite
> book
> > in the Harry Potter series. PoA is still sitting at number one
> > though, with CoS firmly in last place!
>
Stardustray wrote:
> 1. PoA
> 2. OoTP
> 3. GoF
> 4. SS
> 5. CoS
And I'm going to write that I quite disagree.
I would put this as my own, personal order:
1. OotP and SS/PS tied for first
2. CoS
3. PoA
4. GoF
I think during Goblet of Fire Harry was going through things that I
just couldn't understand... and I just wasn't a fan of the basic
plot. CoS holds a place special to me because of the Ginny/Harry
relationship which has its root in that book. And the new charactors
and situations of OotP... I'm sure you all now what I mean when I
say that they caused my heart to swell and catch in my throat.
That's all for now!
A very contented Becky
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive