[OOP] The consequences of new informations on existing theories

[melclaros]

No: HPFGUIDX 61801

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Annechan" <Anne at c...> wrote:
> >[SPOILER]
> 
>
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
..

> So this is it ground zero...
>I read Snape's pensieve scene (chapter 28) 
> and my brain was screaming "I knew it, I knew it, those bastards 
> hurted him" 

> <snip>

>  The guys 
> who bullied him are going to have a place in history books,not him


Well that remains to be seen. He is playing a role, and has been 
doing so for years. A very important and dangerous role. The question 
is only what is that role and (still maybe) on which side?  



> and Remus both agreed that Snape made they're life hell too. That 
> sounds pretty lame to me, like when Malfoy said that the hippogriff 
> attacked him.... 


Except for ONE *teeny* little line.... "well it's more that he just 
*exists*, isn't it." (might not be the exact words but you get the 
drift, right?) They themselves admitted on the spot that he'd done 
*nothing* to deserve what they were doing.





Melpomene

PS--anyone else notice that not only did the group get away with what 
they'd done on the train on the way home after year 4, but 
immediately DID IT AGAIN???