[HPforGrownups] Re: OOP: Chapters 26 and 28...

[Star Opal]

No: HPFGUIDX 61867

First Star Opal, that is to say I, wrote:
> > Finally, I found myself thinking, 'What if Harry had listened and
>tried to
> > get Snape to start teaching him again?' I mean after Snape had
>cooled off a
> > little (and been order to start teaching Harry again) what would
>have
> > happened?

Then Professor Monkshood wrote:
>I don't know whether Dumbledore wants them to try again in the
>future.  He seems to regret not teaching it himself.  But I live in
>hope that the Occlumency lesson would continue

I'm afraid you didn't understand me. I meant after Harry looked in the 
Pensieve and Snape threw him out. Sirius and Lupin told Harry that he had to 
take Occlumency, and Lupin would talk to Snape. (I think chapter 29?) Harry 
didn't listen, and didn't even do his 'emotional excersises' much less go 
talk to Snape about continuing. That's what I meant.

See, I really thought for a while Harry would. He was handling it all rather 
maturely, and wasn't all mad at Snape. I thought he'd at least try, but he 
didn't. So that's why I was wondering, "what would have happened?"

Star Opal
who doesn't understand Mary GrandPre's interpitation of character 
descriptions at all

_________________________________________________________________
MSN 8 with e-mail virus protection service: 2 months FREE*  
http://join.msn.com/?page=features/virus